Just to get it straight: you are not allowed to run tyres that damage the road and leave traces. Modern studded tyres do not do that, so let's get that urban myth out of the way. I don't know why people keep bringing this up. I put money on it that I'm the only guy in the UK who drove his and Evo or a scoob with studs on over the last 5 years
Anyway, running studs in the UK is not necessary. They have less grip on normal tarmac than non-studded winter tyres and only give significant more grip on ice (which you never get there).
Wintertyres themselves have significant advantages over summer tyres. I have compared my summer and winter tyres regularly in autumn when it's just raining and cold and with summer tyres, you get much more wheelspin and much less grip than with wintertyres.
True, the downside is that are softer and hence less precise on dry tarmac. But face it, whereas 8 out of 10 boyracers on the scoobie and Evo websites in the UK keep waffling about 'precision' and
, most of them never use the friggin' abilities of their cars ! So what's on with this need for "stiff tyres" if you can't use them 250 days per year (because it's raining) and the other days you're a too big sissy or there is too much traffic to do so??
I prefer real world performance and a flexible and predictable tyre is so much more pleasant to drive. At least, you'll be confident keeping your foot down in winter or in wet weather where you'd normally lift off being scared of some poisonous reaction of the car.
I've tried quite a few tyres, especially in Germany (where they are compulsory) and the best ones I've driven are still the Nokians.